March 30, 2011

John Le Carre makes enemies by withdrawing from literary prize consideration

by

John Le Carre may need to watch his back

John Le Carre has blown some literary minds down under: After being announced at a ceremony in Sydney as one of the finalists yesterday for the Man Booker International Prize — which is worth £60,000, or about $96,000 — he issued a statement saying he wanted to be withdrawn from consideration.

“I am enormously flattered to be named as a finalist of 2011 Man Booker International Prize. However, I do not compete for literary prizes and have therefore asked for my name to be withdrawn,” he said, according to an Agence France Presse wire story.

But the respectful withdrawal rankled some — the reporter on this Sydney Morning Herald story, for one, whose lede declared that Le Carre had “snubbed the literary world.”

The same report noted that Booker judges were not sure how to respond. “I don’t think we can give him the prize if he doesn’t want it,” said judge (and novelist) Justin Cartwright. But another judge, Australian publisher Carmen Callil disagreed. “Did Francis Assisi have a say in whether he was made a saint?” she asked, apparently in all seriousness.

Of course, to put the article accuracy in perspective, it also says that American novelist Anne Pyler was also one of the finalists.

But make no mistake the powers that be at planet Booker were pissed. A statement on the Booker’s website from the chair of the judging panel, Rick Gekoski, tersely announced, “John le Carré’s name will, of course, remain on the list.”

 

 

Dennis Johnson is the founder of MobyLives, and the co-founder and co-publisher of Melville House.

  • http://www.brendanmcnallyauthor.com Brendan McNally

    Good for him. I agree with him. He doesn’t need it. When he could have used some literary kudos long ago, the British literary community snubbed his work.

    He’s done just fine outside the literary establishment. We could all learn a lesson from him, since most of us writers aint gonna get shit for consideration by either big publishers or the “swinging dick” literary critics.

    Let’s just focus on finding readers.

    Brendan McNally
    Author of GERMANIA, a Novel

    Who was Hitler’s successor and Why Should you Care??

    http://www.brendanmcnallyauthor.com

  • http://www.brendanmcnallyauthor.com Brendan McNally

    Good for him. I agree with him. He doesn’t need it. When he could have used some literary kudos long ago, the British literary community snubbed his work.

    He’s done just fine outside the literary establishment. We could all learn a lesson from him, since most of us writers aint gonna get shit for consideration by either big publishers or the “swinging dick” literary critics.

    Let’s just focus on finding readers.

    Brendan McNally
    Author of GERMANIA, a Novel

    Who was Hitler’s successor and Why Should you Care??

    http://www.brendanmcnallyauthor.com

  • Ilya Zarembsky

    How dare they keep his name on the list

  • Ilya Zarembsky

    How dare they keep his name on the list

  • Bellona

    That’s weird. Why wouldn’t they take him off the list & give the next best who’d no doubt be grateful? That would keep the whole issue in the headlines for a bit longer too.

  • Bellona

    That’s weird. Why wouldn’t they take him off the list & give the next best who’d no doubt be grateful? That would keep the whole issue in the headlines for a bit longer too.

  • Leperman

    An interesting situation–but your making mock of the Sydney Morning Herald mis-spelling Anne Tyler’s name might carry more force if you hadn’t misspelled Sydney as Sidney in your opening paragraph!

    • Dennis Johnson

      Ha! Touche. Thanks for the heads up. It’s fixed now.

  • Leperman

    An interesting situation–but your making mock of the Sydney Morning Herald mis-spelling Anne Tyler’s name might carry more force if you hadn’t misspelled Sydney as Sidney in your opening paragraph!

    • Dennis Johnson

      Ha! Touche. Thanks for the heads up. It’s fixed now.